Review of Bach's
St Matthew Passion
at
Symphony Hall, Birmingham.

Christopher Morley, Birmingham Post
28 March 2005

  25 March 2005
   
   

J. S. Bach: St Matthew Passion
at Symphony Hall, Birmingham (March 2005)
"Emotion and profound faith"

" Every year on Good Friday Birmingham Bach Choir brings Bach's St Matthew Passion to Symphony Hall, and every year this towering masterpiece revealing consummate technique, depth of emotion and profound faith comes up powerful and fresh.
Bach must of course take the credit for much of this, but also must the performers, who under Paul Spicer's direction respond invigoratingly to the vast array of styles juxtaposed in the massive score. Dance-metres, operatic-styles, arias, dramatic outbursts and liturgical chorales all combine in this universal expression, and on Friday all of these were lightly, unobtrusively welded into a strongly communicative entity.
The BBC is a large choir, even when, as here, split into two cohorts, but its approach brings dynamic light and shade, sensitively weighted tone, and a sure feel for rhythmic phrasing. Why doesn't Radio 3 ever take these unsurpassable performances? Is it easier to toddle along to routine carvings nearer home? The time is not outside living memory when such events from the Midlands were a regular feature."

MORE